Pregnant Nurse Declared Brain Dead—Hospital Won’t Let Her Die Under Georgia Abortion Law

Adriana Smith, a 30-year-old registered nurse from Atlanta, has been maintained on life support for over 90 days despite being declared brain dead early in her pregnancy. Hospital officials cite Georgia's abortion restrictions as the reason they must continue life-sustaining measures until her fetus reaches viability.

About Adriana Smith

• Adriana Smith, a 30-year-old pregnant nurse from Atlanta, was declared brain dead over 90 days ago but has remained on life support against her family's wishes due to Georgia's strict abortion ban.
• Georgia's law prohibits abortion after 6 weeks of pregnancy. If a pregnant woman is declared brain dead, doctors must maintain life support until the fetus is viable or can be delivered.
• Smith's family has voiced outrage, saying they have no say in the situation which they describe as "torture." Her mother has criticized the hospital and lawmakers for removing their ability to make end-of-life decisions.
• Smith's family and advocates continue calling for changes, arguing medical decisions should be left to families and providers, not mandated by the state.

A Medical Crisis

Smith's medical crisis began when she experienced severe headaches approximately nine weeks into her pregnancy. According to family accounts, she sought care at a local hospital, but staff did not perform diagnostic imaging such as a CT scan. The following day, Smith was found unresponsive and subsequently declared brain dead due to multiple cerebral blood clots.

"It's torture," Smith's mother, April Newkirk, told reporters. "We have no say in what happens to our daughter's body. The hospital and state have taken that choice from us."

Georgia's abortion law, enacted after the 2022 overturning of Roe v. Wade, prohibits termination of pregnancy after cardiac activity is detected—typically around six weeks. This legislation includes provisions requiring continued life support for brain-dead pregnant women until the fetus can be safely delivered, regardless of family wishes or previously stated patient preferences.

The American Nurses Association's Code of Ethics emphasizes respect for patient autonomy and dignity throughout the life continuum, including end-of-life care. However, nurses working in states with strict abortion restrictions increasingly face conflicts between their professional ethical standards and legal requirements.

Recent data from the Guttmacher Institute indicates that 26 states have implemented or are likely to implement abortion restrictions following the Dobbs decision. Fourteen of these states have near-total bans, while others have restrictions beginning at various gestational ages. 

As Smith's case continues to unfold, nursing professionals across the country are watching closely, recognizing the precedent it may set for future patient care scenarios. The intersection of state legislation, medical ethics, and family autonomy presents challenges that will likely require ongoing dialogue among healthcare providers, ethicists, legal experts, and patient advocates.

🤔 Nurses, what did you think of this story? Share your comments in the forum below.