$15B From Nurse Practitioner Home Visits Prompts Humana Medicare (MA) Reform Push

WSJ reports that Humana, the second-largest Medicare Advantage (MA) insurer, is publicly supporting significant reforms to billing practices that have generated billions in additional payments for the industry—particularly those tied to diagnoses made by nurse practitioners during at-home visits. This marks a notable shift in the ongoing debate over how MA plans are paid and the role of nurse practitioners in risk assessment and documentation.

Key Issues Raised: Nurse Practitioners and Billing Practices

Recent scrutiny of Medicare Advantage billing has intensified as Humana, a leading insurer, backs reforms to limit payments tied to diagnoses made by nurse practitioners during at-home visits, raising significant questions about industry practices and oversight

Diagnoses from Nurse Practitioner Home Visits

• MA plans are reimbursed more for patients with greater documented health complexity, incentivizing insurers to record as many diagnoses as possible.
• Humana has proposed that diagnoses made solely during insurer-initiated home visits by nurse practitioners should not trigger extra payments unless those diagnoses are also documented in another medical setting, such as a health-risk assessment outside the home or a visit with a non-home-based provider.
• The Wall Street Journal and Reuters report that these at-home visits, which are not always linked to active treatment, generated $15 billion in additional revenue for insurers over three years.

Ethical and Clinical Implications for Nurse Practitioners

• Reports indicate nurse practitioners have been trained to record a wide range of diagnoses during home visits, sometimes including questionable or obscure conditions not previously documented by the patient’s primary care provider.
• This practice raises ethical concerns for nurse practitioners, who may feel pressured to document conditions that maximize insurer reimbursement rather than accurately reflect patient health.

Industry and Legislative Response

• Humana’s position is echoed by UnitedHealth Group, which has also stated support for policies that require in-home clinical visits to meet the highest standards, including follow-up care, care navigation pathways, improved reporting, transparency, and annual audits on health risk assessments (HRAs).
• Lawmakers are considering proposals to eliminate payments for certain insurer-driven diagnoses and to implement broader reforms to the MA payment system, with the Congressional Budget Office estimating these changes could save taxpayers $124 billion over ten years.
• The Department of Justice is investigating UnitedHealth Group for upcoding practices related to these billing methods.

Implications for Nurse Practitioners and Nursing Practice

Professional Integrity and Documentation

• Nurse practitioners must ensure all diagnoses are based on thorough, evidence-based assessments and not influenced by financial incentives.
• Accurate documentation is essential for patient safety, continuity of care, and compliance with ethical and legal standards.

Patient Trust and Advocacy

• Overdiagnosis or misclassification can undermine patient trust, lead to unnecessary interventions, and complicate care coordination.
• Nurse practitioners play a vital role in advocating for patient-centered reforms and must remain vigilant in upholding the highest standards of care.

Staying Informed and Engaged

• Nurses and nurse practitioners should stay current with regulatory changes, participate in ongoing education about compliance and ethics, and report any concerns about inappropriate practices.
• Engaging in policy discussions helps ensure that reforms benefit both patients and the nursing profession.

Humana’s support for curbing certain Medicare Advantage billing practices places nurse practitioners at the forefront of a national conversation about ethics, documentation, and patient care. As reforms move forward, nurse practitioners must balance regulatory compliance, professional integrity, and patient advocacy to ensure that Medicare Advantage truly serves the needs of America’s seniors.

 

🤔 Nurses: what are your thoughts on this issue? Let us know in the discussion forum below.