Correctional Nurse Accused of Misusing Benadryl—Now She’s Suing for Wrongful Arrest
Jessica Marie Cotney, a former nurse at Clayton County Jail in Georgia, faced a legal dilemma in May 2023 after being charged with providing forbidden items to inmates-her alleged offense was administering Benadryl. Although the charges were ultimately dismissed, Cotney says the experience has had a profound impact on her personal and professional life. “It ruined my life,” she reflected, describing the toll the arrest has taken. Cotney maintains that she followed standard procedures by handing the medication to another nurse for administration, yet she was later accused of introducing contraband and obstructing an officer. With the charges dropped, Cotney has now filed a lawsuit against the county, alleging wrongful arrest.
Correctional Nursing: Not Your Average Day at the Clinic
Correctional nursing is far from a typical clinical role and it requires balancing patient care with strict security protocols in a highly structured environment. Approximately 27,743 nurses work in U.S. correctional facilities (including jails and prisons) . They have to navigate strict protocols that mix healthcare with security.
Cotney's case is all about the tricky territory of "scope of practice." She argues in her lawsuit that the jail's rules allow nurses to give meds like Benadryl without a doctor's green light. This is often the norm in correctional settings where doctors aren't always on speed dial.
The Complexity of Medications Behind Bars
Medication protocols in jails are highly complex and require strict adherence-any deviation can lead to serious consequences for both staff and inmates. Even over-the-counter meds like Benadryl are under tight scrutiny.
In Cotney’s case, confusion arose when she was accused of introducing contraband, with the Sheriff’s Office stating that both she and a correctional officer were implicated in the incident. This situation highlights how routine nursing responsibilities in correctional settings can quickly become entangled with security concerns, sometimes leading to unexpected and serious consequences for staff.
Lessons for Nurses in Correctional Setting
For nurses considering a career in correctional healthcare, Cotney’s experience serves as an important reminder of the unique challenges in this field. Experts recommend several best practices:
-
always ensure medication protocols are clearly documented in writing
-
maintain thorough and accurate records of every action and decision
-
understand the chain of command within the facility
-
stay informed about your legal rights and responsibilities
These steps can help nurses navigate the complex intersection of healthcare and security that defines correctional nursing.
Lessons and Calls for Change
Cotney’s ongoing legal battle is drawing attention to broader issues in correctional healthcare, highlighting the need for clearer communication and better understanding between medical staff and correctional administrators. Her case has sparked calls for enhanced training and standardized protocols that align nursing standards with correctional policies, as well as stronger oversight and accountability within jail and prison healthcare systems.
Advocacy groups and professionals emphasize that these reforms could help prevent miscommunication and policy misinterpretation, which can have serious consequences for both healthcare workers and the people they serve.
As Cotney seeks justice for her experience, her case serves as a reminder of the importance of legal advocacy, ongoing education, and support networks for nurses working in these challenging environments.
🤔What do you think? Share your thoughts in the discussion forum below.
If you have a nursing news story that deserves to be heard, we want to amplify it to our massive community of millions of nurses! Get your story in front of Nurse.org Editors now - click here to fill out our quick submission form today!
