Are School Nurses Being Replaced By Athletic Trainers? Iowa Considers School Staffing Bill

Iowa lawmakers are considering a bill that would allow school districts to employ either school nurses or athletic trainers to provide health services to students. This proposed legislation, known as House Study Bill 10 (HSB 10), aims to give schools more flexibility in staffing decisions.

The bill has sparked debate among educators, health professionals, and lawmakers. Supporters argue that it provides rural and smaller school districts with more options to meet their staffing needs. However, the Iowa School Nurse Organization opposes the bill, urging voters to reject it and instead advocate for increased funding to hire more school nurses.

Addressing Healthcare Workforce Shortages

Currently, Iowa schools are required to employ a nurse, aiming for a ratio of one nurse per 750 students. However, some districts, particularly in rural areas, are finding it challenging to fill these positions. 

This proposed legislation, introduced by Rep. Shannon Lundgren (R-Peosta), aligns with Iowa's broader efforts to address healthcare workforce shortages across the state. In her recent “Condition of the State” address, Governor Kim Reynolds emphasized the need for more medical professionals in various parts of Iowa. By allowing schools to hire athletic trainers in addition to - or instead of - school nurses, the bill could potentially alleviate some of the pressure on the nursing workforce while still ensuring that students have access to qualified healthcare professionals.

Lundgren said of her bill: "What I would like to do is work towards that middle ground. Not replacing our school nurses. That was never my intent. But giving the flexibility to our schools to have somebody with some degree of medical training that can do a little bit more than a teacher with maybe medication training or something of that sort."

The flexibility offered by this bill could be particularly beneficial for rural or underserved areas where recruiting specialized medical professionals can be challenging. It provides an opportunity for schools to tailor their healthcare services to the specific needs of their student population and the available local workforce.

Expanding Healthcare Options in Schools

This proposed change comes as part of a broader trend in Iowa's education policy. Recent legislative sessions have seen several bills aimed at reshaping K-12 education in the state, including measures that affect staffing requirements, curriculum, and school district operations.

The proposed bill aims to provide school districts with more flexibility in how they approach student health care. By allowing the choice between school nurses and athletic trainers, the legislation recognizes that both professionals can play vital roles in maintaining student well-being. This approach could potentially increase the availability of healthcare services in schools, particularly in areas where recruiting specific medical professionals has been challenging.

School nurses have traditionally been the primary healthcare providers in educational settings, offering a wide range of services from health education and immunization monitoring, to administering medications and managing chronic conditions. They also play a crucial role in health screenings and coordinating care with families and healthcare providers. Not surprisingly, groups representing individuals with disabilities, school nurses, and other school organizations have expressed concerns about the legislation.

Athletic trainers, on the other hand, specialize in preventing, diagnosing, and treating muscle and bone injuries and illnesses. Their expertise can be valuable in schools with active sports programs, but their skills can not replace everything that school nurses do.

It's important to note that this bill is still under consideration and has not yet become law. The Iowa legislative session for 2025 began on January 13, so discussions and potential votes on this and other education-related bills are likely ongoing.

Potential Impact on Student Health Services

While the proposed bill offers more options for schools, it also raises questions about the potential impact on student health services. School nurses and athletic trainers have different areas of expertise, and their roles in a school setting can vary significantly.

The challenge for school districts, if this bill passes, will be to ensure that they can provide comprehensive health services to all students, regardless of which type of healthcare professional they choose to employ.

As the debate unfolds, one thing is clear: Iowa is exploring new ways to ensure students receive the health care they need, even if it means thinking outside the (bandage) box. And for the nurses out there, perhaps this is a reminder that your unique skills are truly irreplaceable—after all, who else can find a vein on the first try or decipher a doctor's handwriting?

School nurses: what do you think of this proposed legislation? Share your thoughts on our Instagram!