Bystander Or Nurse: When Being Off-Duty Gets Complicated
By Lee Nelson
Decades ago, Ann Rhodes and her husband were coming home from a movie on New Year’s Eve when a car passed them and spun out of control into a field. One person was thrown from the vehicle, which then tragically rolled onto him.
“We stopped and got out of the car. One man was still in the vehicle, but he survived because he had his seat belt on. He had minor injuries,” Rhodes says.
When she got to the other man, he was still alive. Rhodes, an RN with a master’s degree in nursing, took off her coat to put over him and held his hand. Moments later, he died.
“It was pretty awful, and we haven’t gone out on that holiday since. But I believe it is in most people’s instinct -- especially a mother’s instinct -- to protect others. I don’t think I could not help someone. Most people would stop – nurse or not – to see if they could help,” she says.
A Nurse’s Dilemma
Unfortunately, it’s not always as simple as just trying to help. The dilemma of whether or not to get involved while off-duty can be quite a difficult situation for nurses and other healthcare professionals to find themselves in.
Though the accident she witnessed affected her deeply, Rhodes also understands why a nurse might not stop to help. After attempting to render aid, some nurses have actually been the subjects of legal action.
“Being sued changes the way you think and the way you practice your profession,” she says.
When The Law Is Not Enough
Every state has some form of a Good Samaritan Law, which is designed to protect citizens from being sued or charged criminally for any injuries or death after they’ve stopped to help a stranger. The law is meant to encourage bystanders to render emergency assistance by legally protecting everyone, no matter their profession. However, the law doesn’t provide complete immunity to a willing rescuer.
In a clinic or hospital setting, nurses are often protected through professional liability or Error and Omissions insurance. Rhodes discusses some of the aspects of that protection.
“There will be some exceptions, like if the nurse does something that is a violation of the law. Lots of policies have exclusions that include things like risky and unclear behavior, or an assault against a patient. If they perform a procedure and do something they are not trained to do, then that’s a different story.”
Similarly, the Good Samaritan law also does not cover you if you do something reckless. An example of recklessness would be starting to render aid, then stopping and leaving before the patient has been stabilized or other help has arrived.
However, if you give a good faith effort given the circumstances, you have probably met your legal requirements and will likely be covered. However, that doesn’t mean you won’t get sued.
“People can file a lawsuit against anyone. The issue is whether they can collect,” Rhodes says.
“Even if the lawsuit isn’t successful, it still takes an emotional toll on the person being sued. It will be costly too, even if the person being sued did everything right. They have to defend themselves.”
Enabling Bystander Response
The American Nurses Association (ANA) states on its website that registered nurses have consistently been reliable responders, even when it puts their own safety or well-being at risk.
Yet others struggle with the call to respond for a variety of reasons.
These may include not having adequate support to meet the needs of the patient, concern about professional ethics, or legal protection while providing care.
Fortunately, the ANA and other national associations are partnering with government groups, employers, and others to help. By implementing policies that enable registered nurses and others who provide care to respond without fear, it helps to ensure that the needs of the American public are met during any kind of disaster.
Assessing An Emergency Situation
So what should you do if you find yourself in an emergency situation?
Carolyn Buppert, a healthcare attorney and author of the book, “The Primary Care Provider's Guide to Compensation and Quality: How to Get Paid and Not Get Sued ,” offers some sage advice.
“Nurses are not obligated to help,” she says. “In an emergency situation, it’s tough to think of precautions or liability. But what should a nurse think about when she comes upon an individual or group of people who need medical attention outside of the workplace?”
Buppert recommends several questions to ask before rendering aid:
- What does this person need?
- How much of an emergency is this?
- What do I have to offer?
- Is anyone already helping?
- Am I sufficiently educated and experienced to provide a useful service to this person?
- What is the potential for physical danger to myself?
- What are the chances that EMS will be here soon?
- What is the likelihood that EMS will get here in time?
“The law can get tricky in certain situations. For instance, if a nurse works for a hospital, and a discharged patient calls the nurse or approaches her or him in a shopping mall asking questions or requesting services or advice, the nurse should decline to provide any services or advice, and tell the patient to contact their physician’s office,” Buppert says.
“If the nurse gives advice and the advice is wrong and the patient suffers some adverse outcome, the nurse could be sued, and there is no Good Samaritan law that would protect the nurse,” she adds.
Preparing Before An Emergency
Not every form of "helping" is covered by Good Samaritan laws. Some states’ laws cover motor vehicle accidents, but not all incidents or strangers' needs on the street are included in such coverage.
Buppert gives one last suggestion for all nurses. “My advice to nurses is to look up the Good Samaritan law in your state and see what protection it offers. Many off-duty nurses will help others without thinking of the possible consequences to themselves,” Buppert comments. “That’s admirable, but it doesn’t hurt to spend a few minutes looking at your state’s law to see what protections are available at a time when there is no emergency.”
Lee Nelson of the Chicago area writes for national and regional magazines, websites, and business journals. Her work has recently appeared in Realtor.org, Nurse.org, Yahoo! Homes, ChicagoStyle Weddings, and a bi-weekly blog in Unigo.com.
Next Up: The Day That Made Me Rethink It All!